Skip to main content

Why asking students for book recommendations is a good thing

For the love of books

ONE bright afternoon at school, one of my Year 7 students approached me after class to ask me one of the greatest questions anyone could ever ask an English teacher: "Sir, what books do you recommend I read?" This was followed by, shockingly, "I am reading Pride and Prejudice right now, but I also like Charles Dickens." Here was a student, in Year 7 mind you, so keen on reading and expanding her mind, whilst surrounding herself with only some of the best company of authors already.

I needed a moment to recover from her question.

I next thought, how do I answer this enquiry? So many novels, so much literature at the tip of my tongue, and my mind kept spawning more suggestions with each passing moment. However, these were books that I enjoyed reading growing up. Perhaps she would not share my admiration of them in the slightest bit. What genres does she tend to favour? Maybe it's not science fiction after all, maybe it's not Tolkien. I needed time to prepare my response, so I settled for: "Come back tomorrow after class, and I will give you a list of books to consider."

That evening I thought about several things, but the one reflection that came to mind foremost was the common practice of teachers to continually select literature and materials in their lessons that they had themselves done so many times before. Content that they were so familiar with that they could arrive at school twenty minutes before class started and have a tattered copy of reading comprehension questions for a particularly well-known novel ready for the photocopier's bright lights.

Why the stagnation? Why the laziness and desire for routine? We have all been guilty of it before. I know we have our own lives to live after school, but why not take a delightful evening and read a new novel or a new poem and come up with fresh, insightful activities for our students to work on? Not only will it stimulate their minds, but ours as well. Reading something new for the betterment of our students. We get to enjoy our profession even more.

I know many have done it already, while it might not be possible for others as there are usually certain curriculums in place throughout most schools. Also it is more time consuming. Nevertheless, that is not always the case I think. We have opportunities to select some works to study. At the very least, passages to be analysed for content, themes, sentence structures, characters and so forth - making it work within the boundaries provided by the school. When you get a chance, take it.

Which brings me back to my bright student's request and another thought: Too many times we choose to have our students study literary material that we know in all their intricacies, which have stood the test of time, and that we think must be read. And that is fair enough, they are fantastic books. Yet, we should also make a better effort to discover what genres and titles our students like - no matter how silly we think they are - and incorporate them in our lessons. At least every so often.

The classics will always be there, ready to be explored when the time comes. Perhaps it is I who needs to ask someone, a student perhaps: "What new treasure do you recommend I read?"

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Culture shock in Tokyo

WHEN I lived in London, once upon a time, I remember the concrete beatings my shoes used to take walking from my flat to the station, the station to the next destination. That combined with the London general pace contributed to a reasonably fast deterioration of the soles of my shoes. And I thought that was pretty bad. Until I encountered Tokyo’s unforgiving concrete.
I love to walk and explore whenever I move to or visit any and all cities. It’s a vital step in the initial introduction to my new surroundings, overcoming any culture shock that I might have. Prior travel experience most certainly helps with the transition that we all go through when moving to a new location as you have some prior knowledge of adapting to unfamilarities too numerous to count sometimes. Still, there are instances when even that is not enough and one becomes overwhelmed with the enormity and scale of a city, its incredible otherness. Where walking is simply not enough. There are times when you just canno…

Why did I move to Japan?

"WHAT brought you to Japan?" This was probably one of the most frequently asked questions that my students asked me (and still do) when I first started teaching here. The answer I generally always gave was "I wanted to get more experience teaching one-to-one English - predominantly business and IELTS prep - but also conversational language." All true. I would THEN expand my answer to the second and more common expected response: "I want to explore the culture of Japan. I love Japanese food, the people and trains. Nature, etc." All true as well. I generally didn't include the stereotypical adoration of manga and anime, even though I am a fan of a handful.
Was I giving a stock answer? Not quite. I have always wanted to teach in Japan, ever since I began my educational career. The history of the country always fascinated me. I generally favoured studying the Edo period, of course. The samurai, bushido, shogun after shogun. I watched "The Seven Samu…

Eating (un)healthy in Japan

I LOVE food. There is no clearer way to say it. I suppose I was born with this eternal love for all things edible from around the world. But it must also be said that my mom created such a variety of dishes for our family over the years that I couldn’t help but learn to love them all - Japanese food very much included.
Japan offers up such a diverse assortment of culinary delights, able to stimulate and hook any taste palate from anywhere on the globe. The amount and variety of different dishes, prices and essential quality available in Japan - particularly Tokyo - is incredible. I remember first arriving in the city and having to adjust to essentially a new diet. I started to eat more rice - it was unavoidable - and now had access to an unlimited amount of bento boxes! Such flavours, affordable prices, combinations of vegetables and meats galore. I ate one every day. Sushi was now much cheaper, readily available at “Su-pas’, or supermarkets, and the quality was quite, QUITE a notch a…